![]() |
© Stan Lupo, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0. |
In the following extract from D.H. Lawrence’s “Fish”, he imagines the exuberance of a fish’s life:
Quelle joie de vivre [What a joy to live]
Dans l’eau! [In the water!]
Slowly to gape through the waters.
Alone with the element;
To sink, and rise, and go to sleep with the waters;
To speak endless inaudible wavelets into the wave;
To breathe from the flood at the gills,
Fish-blood slowly running next to the flood, extracting fish-fire;
To have the element under one, like a lover;
And to spring away with a curvetting click in the air,
Provocative.
Dropping back with a slap on the face of the flood.
And merging oneself!
To be a fish!
Do you think fish can experience the joy of living? That they could be happy or sad? There is some evidence that they can. Even though there are differences between our brains and theirs, overall there are quite a few physical similarities between us and fish. Even more so than between us and fruit flies, which scientists often use to study medical problems.
Jonathan Balcombe writes in his book What a Fish Knows:
I believe that the main source of our prejudices against fishes is their failure to show expressions that we associate with having feelings. “Fish are always in another element, silent and unsmiling, legless and dead-eyed,” writes Jonathan Safran Foer in Eating Animals. In those flat, glassy eyes we struggle to see anything more than a vacant stare. We hear no screams and see no tears when their mouths are impaled and their bodies pulled from the water. Their unblinking eyes—constantly bathed in water and thus in no need of lids—amplify the illusion that they feel nothing. With a deficit of stimuli that normally trigger our sympathy, we are thus numbed to the fish’s plight.
There is something to this. Scientists have shown that mice express their emotions on their faces, though we don’t usually notice it because we aren’t looking close enough...and they lack eyelids, so what we do notice are their beady little unblinking eyes, but as mammals we are able to recognize more similarities to us than we see with fish. Yet, we are a lot more like fish than you’d think.
For over the 100 millennia or so our ancestors were fish. That was approximately 518 million to 417 million years ago. The first fish resembled a swimming worm that was vertically flattened. The last of our fish ancestors, evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins calculated, would be our 185-millionth great-grandparents. Twenty million years later, another group of our ancestors, tetrapods, that looked like a cross between a fish and a crocodile, began moving onto land.
During the period fish were our ancestors, they evolved many of the features that we still have today, prompting science writer Natalie Angier write, “everything we can do, fish can do wetter”. While that’s not entirely accurate, as she points out, they did evolve bones, vertebra, spinal cords, skulls, jaws, teeth, tongues, many of our internal organs, arms, legs, wrists and ankles that rotate, and they even gave us opposable thumbs. They also may have given us the ability of internal fertilization, internal pregnancies, and live births.
Fish can also do many things we don’t normally give them credit for. Some can breathe air, walk on land, and climb trees. Others can glide through the air. They stake out territories and defend them from intruders. They keep their homes clean. They have personalities that evolve over time based on their experiences. Some have complex social systems and hierarchies. They can be cooperative and establish reciprocal relationships. Some provide parental care and raise their young. Some have helpers who assist them with this.
You may be sarcastically thinking, “Yeah, right.” We’ll cover some of these later on, but let’s quickly take a quick look at some here.
Joy is a feeling, an emotion. Some consider it to be one of five basic emotions. They arise from hormones that are regulated by the brain’s limbic system and the neuroendocrine system, as determined by external cues, which in this case would be something that generates joy, such as play or chocolate.
Usually evolution doesn’t suddenly give rise to complex systems. It tinkers with and repurposes what is already there. As a result, our neuroendocrine system is very similar that in other mammals and in bony fish, while the limbic system is one of the most ancient parts of our brain. Physiologically, fish have the capacity to feel emotions, but whether they actually do is difficult to confirm.
We know that fish can suffer from depression and the neurochemistry of that is so similar to ours that zebrafish are now being used to develop new treatments for it. Fish that show the signs of depression recover when the antidepressants fluoxetine and diazepam—also known as Prozac and Valium, respectively—are added to their water.
For a number of reasons, zebrafish, like fruit files, are also used in medical research, including for studying arthritis. Fish do get arthritis. And you know how new mothers get “mommy brain” where their behavior and cognitive functions change? Well, small fish called sticklebacks get that too, except that in their case, it’s the males that get it, since they’re the ones who care for their young by circulating water around the eggs, keeping the nest clean, warding off predators, and retrieving stray fry, while the mother goes off to do her own thing.
Zebrafish are also used to study addiction. When given the choice, the fish will repeatedly dose themselves with the opioid hydrocodone, which is usually prescribed to treat pain, and they’ll even enter risky situations to get it. They also show signs of addiction, and withdrawal when going cold turkey. When given naloxone, a drug that counters the effects of opioids, the fish reduced their requests for hydrocodone. This isn’t surprising since they have the same receptor and neurotransmitters as we do for our reward system.
Like us, rats like to play and when they do, their brains release natural opiates and dopamine, a neurotransmitter and hormone that is involved in emotions, mood, motivation, movement, learning, and the reward system, among other things. It’s often called the “feel-good neurotransmitter”. All mammals have dopamine systems, and so do fish. Goldfish actively seek out amphetamines, which cause their brains to release dopamine, and they avoid pentobarbital, which inhibits its release.
In humans, dopamine suppression is associated with depression, stress, anxiety, low motivation, inability to concentrate, feeling hopeless, and being tired, but having difficulty sleeping. Some of these symptoms are detected in mice, fruit flies, and fish, making them good models for studying depression and other chronic ailments.
The New York Times article “Fish Depression Is Not a Joke” quotes biology professor and researcher Julian Pittman, with Troy University in Alabama saying, “The neurochemistry [in us and fish] is so similar that it’s scary”. That same article quotes other researchers who say the leading cause of depression in fish is probably boredom, since they are so naturally curious and crave novelty.
![]() |
© Elaine Molina Stephens, 2024. |
If you like this, please subscribe below to receive an email the next time I post something wondrous. It's free.